
Welcome back to The Political Spectrum! It’s Thanksgiving week, so that means it’s time to enjoy a feast with family and friends if that’s your thing, get ready for Black Friday or Cyber Monday shopping or just kick back. We have a few stories in the pike for you this week. But for now, here’s a light political breakdown. Remember, this newsletter relies on paid subscribers like all y’all. And I can’t help but be thankful for your support.
The 2026 midterm had enough shocks to last a lifetime. But the most jaw-dropping ones were Scott Colom’s victory in Mississippi against incumbent Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith and Annie Andrews’s against Sen. Darline Graham in South Carolina. In addition, Democrats got within four points the governor’s race in Alabama, within nine points in the Senate race there and within striking distance in the Louisiana Senate race.
So what the hell actually happened? How did Democrats do so well in the heart of what was once the Confederacy? To better understand this, I decided to break down some common threats between Colom’s victory in Mississippi, Andrews’s in South Carolina and Jamie Davis nearly beating Republican Rep. Julia Letlow in the Senate race in Louisiana.
(Side note: Angie Nixon in Florida surprised many with how close she got in her race against Republican Sen Ashley Moody, who replaced Marco Rubio. But Florida is far more racially heterogeneous, specifically with its large Latino population, so it’s difficult to do a straight comparison. For a breakdown on the Latino vote in Florida and Nixon’s performance, read here).
Republicans with little experience on the national stage
Despite what anyone says, running for Senate is vastly different than running for any other type of seat and this election cycle proved it. All three Republicans did not live up to expectations in deep-red states. One reason for this is possibly because they were thrust into their roles.
In South Carolina, Darline Graham became a senator after the death of her brother Lindsey Graham in July. Trump immediately recommended she replace him and then shortly thereafter, suggested she run for a full six-year term. But her lack of experience showed in her primary debate with Rep. Ralph Norman, a member of the House Freedom Caucus. While she won the primary, it proved she was eminently beatable and Andrews did just that.
The same can go with Hyde-Smith. In 2018, Phil Bryant nominated Hyde-Smith to fill out the Senate term of Sen. Thad Cochran, who resigned due to his declining health. Almost immediately, she showed signs of weakness. Chris McDaniel, who had run against Cochran, siphoned off about 16 percent of the vote in the original race and she only beat former U.S. Agriculture Commissioner Mike Espy by about 7.3 points. In a rematch in 2020, she beat Espy in a rematch by about 10 points in a state Trump won by more than 16 points.
Louisiana is perhaps the most peculiar of all of these. Trump endorsed Letlow against Sen. Bill Cassidy as revenge for the Republican incumbent voting to convict Trump for the president’s actions on Jan. 6. Letlow overperformed Trump on the ballot, according to Split Ticket.
She also gained plenty of goodwill when she ran in a special election in 2021 after the death of her husband Luke Letlow from Covid-19. But she faced a bruising primary where even the anti-Cassidy vote split between her and Treasurer John Fleming, with Cassidy not making the runoff. Letlow having her own electoral record and presence likely saved her, but the fractious nature of the primary likely played a role in the general election because voters took exception to Trump wanting to clear the field.

Redistricting efforts and the Callais effect
By far the most consequential decision that disproportionately affected southern states was the double barrel of President Donald Trump’s requests for state legislatures to redraw their congressional maps and the Supreme Court’s Louisiana v. Callais decision. The latter all but killed Section II of the Voting Rights Act of 1965, which prohibits voting practices that discriminate on the basis of race.
Republicans then felt the license to go even further on redistricting. In Louisiana, immediately passed a new map that eliminated one of its majority-Black districts. In Mississippi, Gov. Tate Reeves has expressed his desire to redraw the map, which would alter the 2nd district currently held by Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.).
And in South Carolina, efforts to redraw the congressional map to eliminate Rep. James Clyburn’s 6th district failed.
It didn’t matter whether these efforts were successful or a bust. They signaled that Black political power would be compromised and led to increased voter turnout among Black voters. Which leads to the next point.
Matching–or beating–Kamala Harris’s numbers in majority-Black areas
All three states are incredibly racially polarized, meaning that Democrats need to not only win in Democratic-leaning counties: they need to boost voter turnout.
This means getting near, matching, or even outpacing Kamala Harris’s voter turnout in 2024. In 2024, 766,870 people voted for Kamala Harris. In 2026, roughly 720,521 people voted for Davis.
And an even deeper look shows why Davis missed. East Carroll Parish is the Blackest parish in Louisiana, with about 63 percent of its residents being Black. In 2024, Harris received 1,338 votes, but in 2026, Davis recieved 1,328 votes, only ten fewer than Harris received.
Compare that to Williamsburg County, S.C., which is about 64 percent Black. In 2024, Harris won about 60 percent of the vote while Andrews won 69 percent of the vote.
The same proved true in Mississippi. Claiborne County is about 86 percent Black. The voting patterns essentially match the racial breakdown. In 2024, Harris won about 83.2 percent of the vote and won about 2,880 votes. Colom would build on this lead and win about 87.4 percent of the vote and 2,915 votes. That made a difference in a race decided by 8,031 votes overall
Republicans who received lower turnout than Trump
The inverse of this overperformance is relatively weak performance for Republicans. The New York Times examined voting demographics in each state and found that white voters made up a smaller share of the vote in all three states: In Louisiana, their share dropped by four percentage points; in Mississippi it fell by five points; and in South Carolina, the white share slid by three points. It should be noted that in all three of these states, white people make up a significant share of the voting population, but even a small slip can cause a shift.
In addition, it appears that Republican voters did not heed Trump’s pleas to pretend he was on the ballot.
Take a look at Allendale County, the blackest county in South Carolina, with Black people making up about 67.5 percent of its population. In 2024, Harris received 71.62 percent of the vote, or 2,165 votes. In 2026, Andrews received 213 fewer votes, but won 77.86 percent of the vote. Why? Because while Trump received 813 votes in 2024, Graham received only 533 votes, about a 34 percent decrease.
The same goes for Claiborne Parish, La. In 2024, Trump won more than 60.5 percent of the vote, and 3,522 people voted for him. In 2026., that number dropped by about 5 points for Letlow and while she still won Claiborne, she earned only 2,603 votes.
It’s not clear what drove this low turnout. Trump had been bleeding with white voters without degrees. These are the people whom pollsters missed in Trump’s three presidential races and it’s entirely possible they just dropped off if he’s not on the ballot or they even began to sour on him amid the Iran war and increased costs.
Of course, none of these races were the same. Louisiana, Mississippi and South Carolina are all unique states with their own histories. At the same time, these individual factors, combined with the general anti-Trump sentiment likely created a climate where Democrats took an opportunity to compete. Whether these same circumstances could repeat themselves is another question. But one thing is for certain: the South is definitely in play.
What I’m reading: Robert Samuels’s excellent piece in The Washington Post about Rep. Shomari Figures and the Voting Rights Act. Geoffrey Skelley over at Decision Desk HQ has a great breakdown of how Colom pulled off the Mississippi miracle that inspired this whole piece.
Your regular Bam Bam post:
That’s it for The Political Spectrum. Reminder that this newsletter is only possible because of paid subscriptions. If you like what you read, subscribe down below. If you want to support a travel budget, you can also send money to Ko-Fi.com/EricMGarcia.



